I am shocked that I didn't read this book as a little girl. It's one that I always knew the title of and thought that I had read but when I picked it up in a used book store, Brickbat*, the week that the Shelf Discovery Challenge began, I knew that I had not read it. I would have remembered the story from which the title comes. The idea of a grandmother whispering into a child's ear, quoting the Bible and hinting that God hated her and loved her twin, "Jacob have I loved and Esau have I hated..." Just chilling. I would have remembered that for sure!
I loved the descriptions of island life in this book: the isolation, the necessity of hard work, the crabbing and fishing duties. I was captivated by the secrecy and whispers surrounding the Captain when he returned to the island. One of the things that I loved best about this book though, was the portrayal of the relationship between Louise and her twin sister Caroline. Louise always resented Caroline, hearing from a young age about Caroline's dramatic entrance into the world and the efforts to save her at birth. Louise's perception that her family loves her less than they love Caroline is only exacerbated by her elderly grandmother's Bible quote, indicating to Louise that not only does her family love her sister more than they love her, but God does as well. Louise's adolescent sibling angst will be familiar to most readers who have siblings. While my relationship with my sisters is very different from that between Louise and Caroline, I identified with Louise's admiration of her sister's incredible singing voice, as I have a sister whose voice is so beautiful and pure that, like Caroline's, it can literally bring tears to your eyes, particularly at Christmas. I love that in the end, Louise thought of that stirring moment so many years before, when Caroline sang "I Wonder as I Wander" at their Christmas concert and the emotions that it brought to her so many years later.
I read Katherine Paterson's other Newberry Award winning book, Bridge to Terabithia as an adult as well. I am sorry that I missed these books as a child and am very glad that I chose to read Jacob Have I Loved, although it was not on my original plan for the Shelf Discovery Challenge.
*Sidenote: I am completely in love with Brickbat and need to devote a post to my praises of it!


Recent Comments