A red spider fiat and matching lavalier necklaces
Women in their 30s all over the country are simultaneously cheering and cursing about the re-release of Francine Pascal's Sweet Valley High books.
There are pictures of me as a 9 year old, on the beach, reading a Sweet Valley High book. I wanted to BE Elizabeth Wakefield. I knew I'd never be cool enough to be Jessica but I could imagine myself with a best friend like Enid (much sweeter than Jessica's rich friend Lila) and a boyfriend like Todd. I eventually was the editor of the school yearbook and I'd like to thank Francine Pascal for introducing me to a character who loved to write (I also thank Lucy Maud Montgomery, Louisa May Alcott, and Patricia Hermes, the author of my all-time favorite YA book, Be Still My Heart*) for their literary-loving girls as well.
The anger that has arisen is because of one of the updates that have been made to adapt the series to today's world- changes like the girls sharing a Jeep Wrangler instead of the red Spider Fiat. Elizabeth is now the editor of the school website, rather than the newspaper. The big uproar is over the news that the girls are no longer "a perfect size 6." They are now "a perfect size 4."
A PERFECT SIZE 4.
No wonder I throw up my hands in frustration when I even think about my body and the ways I wish it were different. I have never been, and will never be a size 4. I wore a size 6 dress to my 8th grade dance. I still remember it because it never happened before and has never happened since. I will never wear a size 6, let alone a size 4 and I have pretty much known that since before puberty. The Sweet Valley twins are certainly not great role models for pre-teen girls anymore today than they were 20 years ago (what with Jessica's seduction of every boy who comes along and the cocaine that killed poor Regina even though she only tried it ONE TIME!) but girls are struggling with body image more now than ever before. And we shouldn't be contributing to that problem by making these fictional girls any thinner than they already were.
Links about this here:
- Gawker
- Oh No They Didn't
- Erin Shea: Totally furious and Just Mad
- Big Fat Deal- a blog I adore
- Elastic Waist
* Be Still My Heart didn't do any wonders for my body image either. Allison, the main character, is envious of her best friend who, of course, is perfect and blonde. Allison is a brunette and weighs an apparently atrocious 130 lbs. It's not until after Allison gets blonde highlights and loses 8 lbs that the boy she loves (who is, of course, dating her best friend) finally notices her. Can anyone explain to me me why I love this book?




Recent Comments